Challenges of Stress Management: Doctor's Perspective
By Anne Thiel, ND
Stress management is frequently focused on patient intervention, but it can be improved upon by digging into the nuances of the signs of stress and teaching people that coping with stress can improve their outcomes—regardless of their chief complaint. Some signs of stress are obvious, such as areas of tension that regularly occur after weekly meetings with an overbearing boss. Less obvious signs of stress may involve blood pressure or blood glucose readings that defy improvement despite numerous medications and supplements, or gastrointestinal complaints without corresponding pathology or lab diagnoses.
While these nuanced signs are often easier for an objective third party to recognize, helping someone realize the role of stress in seemingly unrelated health concerns may require a different strategy. A common complaint of someone that needs stress management is never feeling rested despite adequate sleep time or feeling excessive fatigue after exercising.
The challenges of stress management can occur in many stages. In early stages of HPA axis activation, ashwagandha can reduce stress and anxiety while L-theanine can promote calm feelings during exposure to stress.* In the later stages of the stress response, B vitamins are necessary for all cells to generate energy.
For the person who does not think stress affects them or do not recognize the signs of stress, asking focused questions, such as how their energy levels fluctuate throughout the day, do they have difficulties falling or staying asleep, or how they feel after eating a meal can be valuable clues. Complementary to a person's history are lab tests that evaluate key hormones and neurotransmitters like cortisol, DHEA, and epinephrine/norepinephrine. Cortisol can provide helpful guidance in developing a plan and potential stage of HPA axis dysfunction, although normal results do not negate complaints of stress or fatigue. A full thyroid panel is also necessary as adrenal and thyroid functions are intimately connected. Lab work before and after working through a plan of action is a great way to provide tangible information regarding efficacy of interventions or supporting the need to adjust the plan.
Most people know they should be getting a good night's sleep, eating less sugar and more vegetables, and managing their stress with yoga or meditation, instead of a pint of ice cream while watching TV. How to manage stress in a manner that restores health and maintains the motivation for healthy habits is the art of medicine. A simple skill for stress management is to bring awareness to the heart rate through deep breathing. Anyone can find their pulse and feel the change that a long exhale brings; this can be done almost anywhere, at anytime.
Physicians often ask patients to do more than just take a pill, so providing them with an organized reference sheet can improve their understanding of recommendations and lead to improved compliance and outcomes. Asking them to fill out a form allows them to play an important role in their care, instead of a practitioner just telling them what to do. Organizing their care in a form that is easily read and referenced allows the person to spend more energy on taking care of themselves, instead of deciphering a treatment plan. This also creates the space to develop a dialogue with patients about their care and for them to take responsibility for their progress, or lack of, in a non-judgmental style. For example, ask them to provide an example of a personal mark of progress or goal, such as having enough energy to join a sports team or not relying on a cup of coffee to make it through the afternoon. This provides more descriptive information than simply rating stress or exhaustion on a scale of 1-10.
Supplement Recommendations for Stress Management*
Supporting sleep and metabolic processes is necessary for all phases of stress management. Different supplements offer certain benefits for the various phases of coping with occasional stress.* Understanding where you fall on the continuum of HPA axis function provides a guide for recommendations. Lab values only tell part of the story; listening to the verbal and non-verbal clues can provide invaluable information.
In early stages of HPA axis activation, calming the nervous system can support cortisol balance. Ashwagandha can reduce stress and anxiety, while L-theanine can promote feeling calm during exposure to stress.* In the later stages of the stress response, supporting appropriate cortisol rhythms is still important as well as supporting energy levels. B vitamins are necessary for all cells to generate energy—particularly in the citric acid cycle and in the mitochondria.* Melatonin is well known for supporting sleep, but it also provides support for immune-modulating activity that may be affected by stress.*
By paying attention to the signs of stress and integrating multiple stress management techniques, you will succeed in coping with occasional stress. We can't avoid or control all sources of stress, but we can always improve how we manage it!
*These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
1. Pratte MA, Nanavati KB, Young V, Morley CP. J Altern Complement Med. 2014; 20(12):901-8.
2. White DJ, de Klerk S, Woods W, Gondalia S, Noonan C, Scholey AB. Nutrients. 2016; 8(1):53.
3. Kennedy DO. Nutrients. 2016; 8(2):68.
4. Carrillo-Vico A, et al. Int J Mol Sci. 2013; 14(4):8638-8683.